The first challenge of the new season for high school volleyball coaches is running a good tryout, so we asked Tod Mattox, the varsity girls’ coach at The Bishop’s School in La Jolla, California, to share some info about how he chooses his team and how he makes the experience rewarding for all.
1. Define who’s eligible for which teams, but build in some flexibility
At Bishop’s, juniors and seniors have to try out for varsity, but there are special exceptions. For instance, if a student has another primary activity – like dance – she might be allowed to try out for JV as a junior.
2. Create a safety mechanism so deserving players don’t get overlooked
As with many schools, players who try out for the varsity at Bishop’s are there by invitation from the coach. But Mattox makes it known that players who don’t get an invitation can contact him and ask to be part of the tryouts if they think they may be one of the 12 best players in the school. “If they think they belong,” he says, “I have no problem giving them a shot.”
3. Make a list with player facts
On the first day of tryouts – or, if possible, before tryouts – have each athlete write down the following things on a note card:
- Name
- Experience level in volleyball
- Club team (if applicable) the previous year
- Who is the best coach you have ever had and why?
- What position do you think is your best? (This prevents the coach from putting a player at a position they haven’t played for an entire tryout and not giving them a chance to shine.)
- How do you feel about playing different positions?
4. Set guidelines for younger players who are better than older players
“For our top 7-9 players, it's a true meritocracy. That is, the best players will make the team and play, regardless of year. However, for players 10-14, the rules change. We might have sophomores who are better volleyball players than seniors, but if the sophomore is not good enough to start (or play a lot) on varsity, we will put her on JV and put the senior on varsity. We believe that being a go-to player on JV as a freshman or sophomore is a good role, better than sitting on the bench on varsity. The parent and the kid will probably say that they want to be with the varsity, but how do you train leadership that way? We try to look at the bigger picture beyond their volleyball skills. We think there’s value to (a young athlete) learning to be a clutch player by being the one their teammates look to. There’s natural growth there.”
5. Do some basic athletic testing
It’s up to the individual coach to decide what’s important, but measuring vertical jump (approach jump touch minus standing reach) and quickness/speed (shuttle run) are 2 of the most important tests.
6. Find the fast learners
The faster the learner, the better the player you’ll have when it really counts. “Two players might be very similar in August but very different in November,” Mattox says. “It’s important for us to look at how they learn. Who pays attention? We might ask them to set and finish with their elbows extended and their hands flat. It’s uncomfortable for many of them to finish like that. Will they focus on doing it, or will they defer to what they’re most comfortable doing? If we’re looking at two players who are the same and we know that one is going to make varsity and one is going to make JV, we want the faster learner on varsity.”
7. Look for hitters with torque
Whether players are attacking a set or just hitting back and forth to a partner, Mattox wants to see that they can generate torque with their upper bodies. “The normal thing (young players) do is hit the ball with the front of their shirt facing their partner. We want the front of their shirt to be facing sideways, and then we want their hips to rotate so they have torque when they hit. That’s something we stress a lot. It’s a trained skill. (Former Stanford coach) John Dunning talks about this a lot in terms of the health of a kid’s shoulder and back.”
8. Run competitive drills that highlight each player’s skill level
During tryouts in the Bishop’s gym, competition ladders and “doghouse rules” (players staying on if they win, coming off if they lose) are popular. Mattox also favors drills with a low player-to-ball ratio so each participant gets as many touches as possible.
Here are 3 drills he uses at tryouts as well as during the season:



